Do Tattoo Artists Judge Your Ideas? (Honest Answer)
Worried your tattoo idea is too basic? Here's what artists actually think, the most common requests we see, and why your idea is valid.
The Short Answer: No
Your tattoo idea isn't as weird, basic, or embarrassing as you think. Professional artists have seen thousands of designs. Nothing surprises us anymore. What matters is that the tattoo means something to you.
That said, we'd be lying if we said we don't have internal reactions to certain requests. Let's talk about the ideas we see constantly, and why none of them actually bother us.
The Classics We See Every Week
Some designs are so popular they've become memes. You've probably seen jokes about:
- Infinity symbols (bonus points if combined with a feather)
- Coordinates of meaningful locations
- Matching couple tattoos
- "Live Laugh Love" and similar scripts
- Anchors with "refuse to sink"
- Dandelions turning into birds
- Roman numeral dates
Here's the thing: these designs are popular because they work. They're meaningful, they look good, and they've brought joy to thousands of people. If you want one, get one.
What We Actually Think
Professional artists care about two things: making art we're proud of and making clients happy. We're not judging your idea. We're thinking about execution.
When you bring us a concept, we're considering:
- Will this design age well at this size?
- Does the placement work for the composition?
- How can we make this uniquely yours?
- What style would serve this idea best?
Our job is to guide you toward the best version of your idea. If we suggest changes, it's not because we're judging. It's because we want your tattoo to look amazing for decades.
When We Might Push Back
There are rare cases where we'll strongly recommend reconsidering:
- Partner names (high regret rate historically)
- Face or hand tattoos as someone's first piece
- Designs that won't read clearly at the requested size
- Placements that will blur or distort badly over time
This isn't judgment. It's experience. We've seen what works and what clients return to cover up. Honest guidance protects you from future regret.
Your Idea Is Valid
The most meaningful tattoos aren't always the most original. A rose for your grandmother, coordinates of where you met your partner, your child's birthdate in Roman numerals. These "basic" tattoos carry real emotional weight.
Don't let internet jokes about common tattoos stop you from getting something you'll love. Come in, share your idea, and let us help you make it the best version it can be.